Your current location:HOME >style >Row erupts over bizarre claim William Shakespeare's works could have been written by a WOMAN 正文
TIME:2024-05-21 16:58:40 Source: Internet compilationEdit:style
William Shakespeare's mastery of the English language has remained unchallenged for centuries.But a
William Shakespeare's mastery of the English language has remained unchallenged for centuries.
But a renowned literary institution has provoked anger by hosting a debate on whether some of the Bard's works could have been written by a woman.
Oliver Kamm, a journalist and author, has written to the Chairman of the London Library to complain about the 'wildly inappropriate' event and its 'promotion of a baseless and anti-intellectual conspiracy theory.'
The 19th century library, which contains one million books, is holding a panel discussion in June with Elizabeth Winkler, the author of the controversial book 'Shakespeare Was a Woman and Other Heresies', which explores 'who the Bard might really be.'
The book looks at 'how the forces of nationalism and empire, religion and mythmaking, gender and class have shaped our admiration of Shakespeare across the centuries.'
A row has erupted over the bizarre suggestion William Shakespeare's works could have been written by a woman
It analyses the 'literary taboo' not to question 'the identity of the god of English literature,' which it's been suggested could involve a 'forgotten woman, a disgraced aristocrat or a government spy' writing some of his works.
The London Library's discussion on such a divisive topic will also involve Sir Derek Jacobi, one of the great Shakesperean actors, and author and critic Stephanie Merritt.
However, Mr Kamm has written to library chairman Simon Goodwin to criticise the 'institution' for holding the event.
He described it as a 'grave misjudgement', adding: 'There is a cost to indulging conspiracy theories, evident in the coarsening of public discourse and the spread of irrationalism.'
Mr Kamm wrote: 'To host a 'conversation' with Shakespeare denialists is a betrayal of the values of literary scholarship and critical inquiry that we hold to.'
He likened it to the Royal Geographical Society holding a discussion with 'flat-earthers.'
Winkler's book explores arguments for possible Shakespeare author candidates including poet Emilia Bassano, playwright Christopher Marlowe, philosopher Francis Bacon and Edward de Vere, 17th Earl of Oxford.
But Mr Kamm commented that 'literary scholars dismiss these fantasies because there is zero evidence to support the notion of concealed authorship'.
The London Library (pictured) is holding a panel discussion with Elizabeth Winkler, the author of the controversial book 'Shakespeare Was a Woman and Other Heresies'
The London Library's (pictured) discussion on such a divisive topic will also involve Sir Derek Jacobi, one of the great Shakespearean actors, and author and critic Stephanie Merritt
Mr Kamm called on the library to add a Shakespeare specialist to the line-up such as Professor Emma Smith, an expert in Shakespeare studies at the University of Oxford.
Another critic of the event was Jonathan Beckman, editor of The Economist's 1843 magazine, who posted on X that he had also written to the director because 'the library is supposed to be a bastion of scholarship.'
The London Library was not available for comment.
Ms Winkler said her book and the London Library discussion was 'not suggesting Shakespeare was female.'
She said her book 'is about the theories that have been put forward over the centuries. It does not argue for any one of them in particular.'
Commenting on Mr Kamm and critics of the library event, she added: 'I'm not sure why these people feel so threatened by a simple library discussion.
'Arguments about the past are a fundamental feature of academic freedom and democratic debate.
'There is nothing dangerous or 'immoral' in exploring this subject. Shutting down discussion is obviously anti-intellectual.'
Sweden beats France, Britain relegated after losing to Norway at hockey worlds2024-05-21 16:53
Drug overdoses reach another record in 2022, CDC says2024-05-21 16:50
Federal data does not show a soaring number of unauthorized migrants registering to vote2024-05-21 16:33
US measles cases are up in 2024. What's driving the increase?2024-05-21 16:25
Storms damage homes in Oklahoma and Kansas. But in Houston, most power is restored2024-05-21 16:02
Coalition's first budget to be unveiled on 30 May2024-05-21 15:39
New apps test AI chatbots to help mental health crisis2024-05-21 15:23
California is still counting votes from Super Tuesday. Experts say that’s normal2024-05-21 15:15
Trump accepts a VP debate but wants it on Fox News. Harris has already said yes to CBS2024-05-21 14:45
Benefit sanctions to ramp up with 'work check2024-05-21 14:12
Hall of Fame outfielder Ken Griffey Jr. to lead Indianapolis 500 field in Corvette pace car2024-05-21 16:03
Punxsutawney Phil and wife Phyllis are parents of 2 babies2024-05-21 16:02
A new Washington state law does not offer cash for reporting hate speech2024-05-21 15:54
Lawsuit seeks to force ban on menthol cigarettes after delays by Biden2024-05-21 15:53
The government wants to buy their flood2024-05-21 15:05
This stinks. A noxious weed forces Arizona national monument's picnic area to close until May2024-05-21 15:05
Tennessee fisherman reeled in a big one. It turned out to be an alligator2024-05-21 14:52
Uyghur activist receives Roosevelt freedom of worship award — Radio Free Asia2024-05-21 14:50
‘The Blue Angels,’ filmed for IMAX, puts viewers in the ‘box’ with the elite flying squad2024-05-21 14:38
Olivia Munn recommends breast cancer risk calculator after diagnosis2024-05-21 14:29